Kya aisi koi hadith ibne maaja mein hai ke ikhtelaafaat ke waqt SAWAADE AAZAM ko pakade raho.?

Aap ka sawal:
kya aisi koi hadees ibne majha me hai?
Agar hai to kya vo sahi hadees hai.


Hadith:
Beshak meri ummat hargiz gumarahi par jama nahee hogi, jab tum ikhtilaaf dekho to tum par lazim hai ek badhe groh ko thaam lena (yani sawad-e-aazam ko).
(Sunan Ibn-e-Maaja:3940)

Jawab:
Ji haan aisi hadith ibn-e-maaja mein maujood hai.
Magar sab se pehli baat to ye hai keh iss mein hadith number ka hawala galat diya gaya hai.
Asal mein ye hadith Ibn-e-Maaja mein Hadith no. 3950 par hai.
Aur hadith poori sanad ke saath iss tarah hai,
حدثنا العباس بن عثمان الدمشقي قال: حدثنا الوليد بن مسلم قال: حدثنا معان بن رفاعة السلامي قال: حدثني أبو خلف الأعمى، قال: سمعت أنس بن مالك، يقول: سمعت رسول الله صلى الله عليه وسلم، يقول: «إن أمتي لا تجتمع على ضلالة، فإذا رأيتم اختلافا فعليكم بالسواد الأعظم»
(3950-سنن ابن ماجة)

Khair, Iss hadith ke talluq se jo ibn-e-maaj mein hai mohadditheen r.h. ne, na sirf Zaeef hi nahee balke Zaeef Jiddan kaha hai, yaani wo hadith jo ibn-e-maja mein hai wo bohat sakht zaeef hai.

Magar dusri hadithaun ko dekhane ke baad, iss hadith ka pehla hissa sahee ho jaata hai aur baad wala hissa zaeef.
yaani,
“Beshak meri ummat hargiz gumarahi par jama nahee hogi”
ye hissa sahee hai.

Aur,
“jab tum ikhtilaaf dekho to tum par lazim hai ek badhe groh ko thaam lena”
ye hissa zaeef (yani sahee nahee hai).

Iss ki wajah kya hai?
Iss ki wajah ye hai ke humein ek aur sahee hadith milti hai jiss mein nabi-e-paak s.a.w. ne iss ummat ke gumarahi par jama na hone ki baat kahi hai.
Aur wo hadith iss tarah hai,
رواه ابن أبي عاصم في ” السنة ” (2 / 1 ورقم 79 – منسوخة المكتب) عن سعيد
ابن زربي عن الحسن عن كعب بن عاصم الأشعري سمع النبي صلى الله عليه وسلم:
يقول:
إن الله قد أجار أمتي من أن تجتمع على ضلالة

Tarjuma:
Ibn-e-Abi Aasim r.h. ne apni kitab “As-Sunnah” mein ye hadith naqal ki hai ke nabi-e-rehamat s.a.w. ne farmaya
Beshak ALLAH ne meri ummat ko mahfooz kar diya hai iss baat se keh wo kisi gumarahi par jama ho.
(As-Sunnah Ibn-e-Abi Aasim 1/2-79)

Ab Ibn-e-Maaja ki hadith ka jo dusra hissa hai to sakhat zaeef hai. kyunki iss ke support mein koi dusri hadith maujood nahee hai jo sahee ho.
Aur Ibn-e-maaj ki hadith ke iss hisse mein, iss ke zo’af ke talluq se 4,4 i’allatein (yani nuqs ya kamzori) payi jaati hain, jiss ke zikar karne ka ye muqam nahee hai, iss ko hadith ki kitabaun mein mohadditheen r.h. ke zariye samazhein.

Aqali dalail:

A. “Beshak meri ummat hargiz gumarahi par jama nahee hogi”
1. Chahe haq ko kitna bhi dabaya kyun na jaye, aur poori dunya zulm wa jaor se bhar jaye tab bhi haq ke manane wale zarur milenge, chahe wo ta’adaad mein kam hi kyun na ho.
2. Jiss tarah ALLAH ne QURAN ki hifazat ki hai ussi tarah ALLAH ne pyare nabi s.a.w. ki AHADITH ki bhi hifazat ki hai. Ye dono qayamat takk baaqi rahengi, to zahir si baat hai ye poori ummat kabhi gumarahi par jama nahee ho sakti.
ALLAH ke nabi s.a.w. ne iss baat ki guarentee bhi le rakhi hai ke ye ummat hargiz gumrah nahee hogi jab takk ke do cheezaun ko mazboot pakade rahehi, Ek Kitabullah, aur dusri Suunat-e-Rasoolullah (Sunnat to hadith ki kitaab mein ki milegi kisi tareekh ki kitaab mein nahee.)

B. “Jab tum ikhtilaaf dekho to tum par lazim hai ek badhe groh ko thaam lena (yani sawad-e-aazam ko)”
1. Ye baat bilkul durust nahee hai kyunki nabi-ekareem s.a.w. ki ummat mein gair muslim bhi aate hain. Agar iss tanazur mein dekha jaye to aaj gair muslim, musalman ke muqabale mein ziyada hain. Iss usool ke hisab se to “SAWAD-E-AAZAM” gair muslim ka groh huwa, aur iss ke chakkar mein musalamanaun ko apna deen hi chorna padhega kyuki aksariyat gair muslim ki hai.
2. Agar bil farz islam mein sirf 2 hi firqe maane jaye, ek Shia’a aur dusra sunni, aur ye dono groh nabi ki ummat hi mein dakhil hain. Kal ke roze agar shia’a ki aksariyat badh jaye to iss hadith ke hisse par amal karte huwe shia’a sawad-e-aazam bann jayega, aur hum ko uss mein dakhil hona padhega.
kya ye dono cheezein kisi ko amnzoor hain?

Que. asked in Faham-e-Quran group

Answer by : Siraj Inamdar
http://www.sirajinamdar.com/index.php/all-que-and-ans/

Agar aap siraj bhai ke Quran aur sahee Hadith ke msgs chahte hain to iss number par “Add Me” likh kar msg send karein.

WhatsApp No.: +918007775053